My lesson learned as a thru-hiker regarding footwear: Give your footwear your greatest attention! What is on your feet is your most important piece of gear. Why? Because footwear impacts your feet, knees, and back. In my opinion, browsing through most other backpacking and camping gear is far more fun. However, great footwear is imperative for a successful thru-hike of the Appalachian Trail, or enjoyable hiking of any length. If there is one piece of gear you should not worry about paying the retail price, it is footwear. (I say this as a very frugal person.) If there is one piece of gear you should visit several stores to try on, it is footwear.
So if footwear is so important, the question becomes: “What is the best footwear I can get for a thru-hike?” The answer is whatever footwear best fits both your foot and your body. Everyone’s feet and body are different, and what is most important is for footwear to totally fit your foot. Most often in my life, I have known a boot or shoe was right for me soon after I started walking around the store in it. However, that came in the midst of putting on many other pairs of boots or shoes which were not the correct pair. Shopping for the correct boots or shoes in past years has sometimes involved traveling to several stores throughout a day. For me, it can be an ordeal.
Many years ago I was trying on running shoes in a shoe store. I found a pair which I thought was the right one, but I wanted to be sure. I walked back and forth at the back of the store. At one point, a saleswoman came by and joked with me that she was going to have to charge me for wearing out her carpet. I took that as a compliment. If I had been trying on footwear for backpacking, it would have been best to have a pack on my back with at least twenty pounds in it. The salesperson would have been entertained by that.
Compensation for the extra weight on your back
Though everyone has a different build, we all have one thing in common: Our feet were designed to support our body as created. For example, I have a thin build, with thin bones, and I have extremely small feet. Add on a backpack full of a week’s provisions, and my feet have pressure they were not designed to take. A backpacker requires footwear which gives extra foot support.
Thus you need different shoes for backpacking than you do for day hiking. People like me, who are small boned and who supinate, which I will get into next, may be more prone to twisting an ankle. Yet all backpackers should be concerned with having good ankle support.
So in addition to having boots which are the correct fit for your feet and body, it is my opinion that boots which go above the ankle assist in preventing ankle injuries. (Make sure they do not rub poorly on your ankle bones which stick out.)
On my thru-hike in 1990, I had heavy boots, which I will also address in a bit. Even with heavy boots, I twisted my ankle a few times. Yet for me, one who has a leg slightly out of alignment, only a few twists in nearly 2,200 miles is incredible in my opinion. My belief is I would have twisted my ankle more times without ankle support. And I did not sprain my ankle. In recent years I did sprain my ankle wearing sneakers in winter and stepping on an uneven surface hidden by a snow covering. Not only was it painful, there was a long recovery process.
Also, most thru-hikers need to be concerned about their knees. I have been told by a footwear expert that footwear has an impact on your knees and your back. This just gets more complicated. The bottom line is footwear needs much attention. So I continue on with an important issue.
Pronation vs. supination
In getting the correct footwear, you need to know whether you pronate, are neutral, or supinate. Note the degree of pronation or supination varies. Pronation means more weight is distributed on the inside of the foot, thus you walk more on the inside of your foot. Supination means more weight is distributed on the outside of the foot. I supinate, and my shoes always wear down on the outside of the shoe, primarily near the heel. A small percentage of people supinate. Figures. A small percentage of people walk with an even distribution. Envy. The vast majority pronate. Most shoes are constructed to compensate for pronators. If you are a pronator, buying shoes should be easier, as many shoes are built with reinforcement in the sole on the inside. For people with an even distribution, “neutral” footwear is what you want. And usually “neutral” footwear is the best us supinators can do. Supinators will have the toughest time finding a quality boot.
Engage in research on Internet sites where the author is an expert in this area, which I am not, and then shop at a quality outdoor recreation store or a quality running store where they employ salespeople who are knowledgeable about footwear, and not pushy.
Yet what is most important is trying on many pairs of boots or trail shoes until you find what is best for you.
Shoe shopping is challenging work for me since I supinate so much. But not knowing about supination stuff in 1990, I was not completely prepared with my footwear, and it caused me much pain the second half of my journey. And I will now confess what I did.
I admit my mistake
Brace yourself: I backpacked the entire A.T. in one pair of boots, and that was a mistake. Yes I came from the old Boy Scout school and bought extremely heavy leather boots. I even told the person at the outdoor store I wanted boots which would last the entire A.T. He looked at my skeptically, but he got me what I requested. It was a great quality boot.
The positive news: My boots were a great fit. They were snug, with wool socks and wicking liners, without being too tight, and they had just the right amount of toe room. This is the reason I could do the entire A.T. in one pair of boots.
The negative news: Since I supinate, around halfway through the journey, I had worn down the soles enough that there was pressure on the outside of my foot, and my pinkie toe was in pain every morning when I put on my boots. For the last month, I started exerting more effort to walk in a way which compensated for the boot sole being worn down on the outside. But the worn down boots apparently even stressed my back.
Thus in my opinion, once you find “the pair,” buy several pairs, and wear all of them on some long walks before you hit the A.T.
Try many boots and trail shoes on!
If getting good footwear is more of a challenge for you than the average person, go to a store and try on a bunch of boots or trail shoes, and then go home and think it over. Then go back to the store days later and give it a second try. Or go to another store, and do the same thing. Take your time buying this critical piece of gear for backpacking. Do what is best for your body. In the end, I hope you find the boots you deserve.
Hunter